I was back in 2011 today and listening to a Greatest Hits album. Now, Greatest Hits albums were banned from the 2001 album listening the first time around and I’ve been even stricter and removed albums which featured new versions of songs or a couple of new songs.
However, the 2011 listening criteria is simply that it’s on the top 100 albums from 2011 based on the Official UK Charts Company’s information.
So I had to listen to 19 of the songs that Pink felt were the best 19 of her songs in 2011.
Out of the 19, I have heard of 10 of them, which is over 50%. Out of the 10 I’ve heard, I like 2 and absolutely hate 4.
I can legit remember her first single ‘There You Go’ being released and I loved that song. That song is on this album. I absolutely hate ‘Get the Party Started’ (don’t @me). It’s awful.
There are two songs on this album which I believe deal with domestic abuse (three if I count ‘Just Like a Pill’ but I’m going to ignore it because it’s main subject is not the abusive relationship).
‘Family Portrait’ is sung from the perspective of a child witnessing parental domestic abuse and I find it incredibly powerful. It speaks about a child apologising for the mum’s behaviour to stop the dad from being so angry, it speaks about how the child has a view that there are good times in the family and wants to find a way to keep the good times, it shows that witnessing domestic abuse is incredibly traumatic for children.
And I listen to it and it hurts, because I know that the times a child see as ‘good’ are the times when the victim is the most controlled; when the victim is the most in pain. When the child is seeing/hearing arguments is when the abuser is fearing a loss of control and needs to regain the control.
And that can be so difficult when the victim leaves. The child is heartbroken to leave the abusive parent and remembers all the good times and questions the victim ‘why couldn’t you stop making them angry?’
And then the family courts step in to allow the abuse to continue because the child is saying they want to see the abuser and the abuser knows the children are an excellent way of controlling the victim.
The second song is ‘Please Don’t Leave Me’.
I’ll be honest, there are so many songs which are portrayed as ‘romantic’ songs which are actually abusive songs, that I am unsure if Pink knew she was singing an abusive song. (For example, One Direction – Steal My Girl)
‘I forgot to say out loud
How beautiful you really are to me
I can’t be without
You’re my perfect little punching bag
And I need you
I’m sorry’
This song contains an abuser explaining how much they need the victim. It includes an explanation of all the things they do wrong in the relationship. It includes an apology.
But please not, the only apology in the song comes after ‘I need you’.
‘I need you, I’m sorry’
No apology for the actions. No, in fact, the actions are the fault of the victim
‘How did I become so obnoxious?
What is it with you that makes me act like this?
I’ve never been this nasty (da-da-da-da-da)
Can’t you tell that this is all just a contest?
The one that wins will be the one that hits the hardest
But baby, I don’t mean it’
The abuser describes their terrible actions, acknowledges the terribleness of their actions. The abuser questions ‘what is it with you that makes me act like this?’ I don’t act like this with other people, just you. You make me act like this.
But I don’t mean it because I need you. And I’m sorry that I need you but I do. So don’t leave me. I need you to stay because, if I’m honest, I like how it feels to be able to treat you this way.
Domestic abuse is so often hidden behind the disguise of romance and it’s not taken seriously because the disguise is so good.
When a couple breaks up and one party won’t let it go, and keeps trying to woo the other one back, through grand gestures, through conversations with friends ‘tell them, i love them, I’ll do anything’. It’s seen as romantic. There’s a term for this now which is good, when we have labels we can have better discussions ‘love bombing’ -like Kanye is doing. It’s abusive. It can happen to initiate a relationship, it can happen when a relationship ends. It makes victims of the primary victim’s friends and family by deluding them that the abuser has good intentions, it also means that the victim’s friends and family become abusers.
When a partner wants the other all to themselves, ‘oh, you’re going out with friends tonight? I wish we had more time together’, it’s romantic….or is it controlling?
Domestic abuse is so intertwined with gender stereotypes that the misogyny of it is overlooked. I think this is very clear in domestic abuse within gay/lesbian domestically abusive relationships as well. The idea that even in same-sex relationships someone should be subservient and that person is the ‘woman/femme’.
Domestic abuse is huge and mostly hidden. Even when it’s in plain sight, it is excused away.
Don’t let it be.
Don’t fall for the excuses. Don’t fall for love bombing.
Also, meh for Pink. If this is the best you had over 10/11 years, it’s not great.