Number 98 in the end of year top 100 albums of 2011 is Nero’s ‘Welcome Reality’.
Apparently, this is a concept album. I can’t work out what the concept is and the Wikipedia page doesn’t tell me. Helpfully, Wikipedia does tell me that there is no clear definition of what a concept album is.
My view is that a concept album should hold tracks which are all connected together. The best concepts, in my view, are those where the music creates a story – like an opera perhaps. Coheed and Cambria’s album ‘Good Apollo, I’m Burning Star IV’ is a good example. Later in the year, I will relisten to Iron Savior’s album ‘Dark Assault’ which was a clear concept album that I was unsure about last year. (side note, I was uncertain about it but put it on the playlist…that was the problem with the original playlist).
Then, there are other concept albums such as Tori Amos’ ‘Strange Little Girls’. I don’t think it’s a sane concept. However, she decided to sing songs originally sung by men, without changing lyrics or pronouns at all. Fine! I guess it’s a concept. I don’t know why it’s a thing but perhaps, it’s a thing.
One of my 2021 albums was a concept album. ‘Worship with Psalms’ was the Psalms set to modern tunes including pop songs….such as Psalm 107 set to ‘Crazy’ by Britney Spears.
If you release a concept album, I think it should be clear what the concept is… and if it’s not, you should explain the concept in so much details that people can’t reference the album without quoting the concept situation…such as people who love the Tori Amos album.
No one is talking about the concept of ‘Welcome Reality’. Although, one critic described it as ‘predictable’ which suggests they immediately understood the concept and knew what songs were coming next….which must make them some sort of musical understanding genius…. I want them to produce an Encanto Reaction video!
You may think that I’m this deep into dissing the album that I must not like it. No, it’s absolutely fine. A couple of excellent tracks, a few good tracks, nothing bad. The problem is that someone said it was a concept album.
If Nero classified it as a concept album, they did it badly and this is a terrible album. If someone else decided it was a concept album, it is a decent album with no concept.